Science Corner - Invasive Goldfish

Kristie Ehrhardt • November 7, 2024

When my daughter was a kindergartener, she “won” a few little goldfish from a school carnival. We brought those little guys home and put them in a small aquarium and gave them all names: Chloe, Biscuit and Sarah. That next summer we added Jack who was rescued from the ring toss game at the 110-degree California State Fair. Eventually Sarah and Biscuit passed away, but Chloe and Jack lived to the ripe old age of thirteen and fourteen. We continuously got them bigger and bigger aquariums and they got so enormous that they didn’t fit in an aquarium net anymore. Sadly, they both passed away and are buried in the backyard.

 

Goldfish (Carassius auratus) are a freshwater fish that is native to southern China. It was originally believed that modern goldfish were a subspecies of the crucian carp (Carassius carassius) or the Prussian carp (C. gibelio), collectively called Asian carp; but through genetic sequencing and investigation of morphology, it is now believed that common goldfish are a domesticated variety of C. auratus. Goldfish belong to the carp and minnow family which were originally reared to be used as fish food. Naturally silver or gray, carp occasionally produced offspring with color mutations that produced red, orange, gold or white fish. These vibrantly colored fish became popular, and people began to put them in ornamental water gardens. Later, these fish began to be selectively bred for their colors, body shape, fin structure and size which resulted in distinct breeds that varied greatly. Not long after goldfish began to be raised indoors and were subsequently introduced into Japan and Portugal and later into the rest of Europe.

 

Goldfish are gregarious and friendly with each other. They have good eyesight and can recognize their owner. They have memory capabilities and can recognize different shapes and colors, can learn tricks and can even be hand fed.

 

Goldfish are hardy and are easy to keep in outdoor ponds because they can bear cooler water temperatures and short periods of low oxygen. They can even survive if ice has formed on the top of the water as long as there is enough dissolved oxygen in the water. And, although considered a freshwater fish, they have been found surviving in brackish water.

 

Some breeds of goldfish can live for decades and can become quite large like my two. Because of this, goldfish often get released into the wild where they become a highly invasive species. Without the restrictions of the backyard pond or aquarium, goldfish released into the wild can grow to be significantly larger than those kept in captivity. They have voracious appetites and outcompete native species for food such as algae and small invertebrates, as well as consuming native species’ eggs and larvae. They swim and graze along the bottom stirring up sediment which increases water turbidity that reduces the amount of sunlight that penetrates the water column which affects aquatic plants and expands habitat loss for native species. Goldfish also have a high reproduction rate which aids in them outcompeting native fish and can hybridize with other carp species further increasing their population numbers. They can also carry bacteria and diseases that may harm native aquatic life.

 

All of these combined intensifies their impact on biodiversity and ecosystem health. The United States Geological Survey has indicated that goldfish have been released into American waterways since the 1600’s. They have become one of the most widespread invasive species of fish in North America. Huge goldfish have even been caught in Lake Tahoe ranging from four to eight inches long and weighing up to several pounds. Biologists believe that the goldfish were introduced into the lake by people that kept them as pets. Although the fish are already in the lake and eradication efforts are taking place, the United States Forest Service Lake Tahoe Basin Management United and the California Department of Fish and Wildlife are urging people not to release their pet fish (or leftover bait fish) into Lake Tahoe or it’s associated waterways. In Minnesota, Colorado and Canada goldfish have become an imposing problem. The Carver County Water Management agency in Minnesota recently removed 50,000 pounds of goldfish from a tributary to one single lake.

 

All drains do not lead to the ocean and indeed, goldfish do make great pets but they are best left in their tanks.


-Kristie Ehrhardt (kehrhardt@tuleyome.org)

Tuleyome Land Conservation Program Manager

RECENT ARTICLES

By Nate Lillge October 2, 2025
Tuleyome was excited to be back in the field at Stebbins Cold Canyon Reserve. Volunteers installed a Chronolog station that will help monitor restoration efforts on the Blue Ridge Trail. This station - a post next to the trail that encourages hikers to take a photo - will help UC Reserve System document the changes at the site without large amounts of resources and time dedicated to monitoring. You can be a part of restoration efforts by taking a photo at the station. Thanks to our volunteers who joined us! Photos from the day are available on Flickr . Check out our website for more chances to help Tuleyome maintain trails! More information about Chronolog can be found on their website . There are currently two cameras at Stebbins - one monitoring big leaf maples and this one on the Blue Ridge Trail . Head to Stebbins and be a part of the restoration efforts!
By Geoff Benn October 2, 2025
Interns Diego, Ellen, and Rithika on the Rotary Pavilion at the Preserve Tuleyome is excited to welcome three new Horticultural Interns for Fall 2025! This is our second year offering this internship, where we pair college students with mentors at Woodland Regional Park Preserve to assist with projects including invasive plant removal, native plantings, and native species monitoring. This year’s cohort includes three UC Davis Environmental Science and Management majors – senior Diego Barraza and sophomores Ellen Jenkins and Rithika Warrier. They will be mentored by longtime Preserve volunteers Jennifer Hogan and Teri Barry. Over the course of the Fall Quarter, the interns will join volunteer crews for work days at the Preserve, providing opportunities for both skill development and networking. The Preserve, which opened to the public in May 2025, is a restored former landfill site that was developed into nature preserve to provide outdoor education opportunities and to protect the rare and endangered plants found on the site. The Preserve is a collaborative effort by the City of Woodland, Tuleyome, Yolo Habitat Conservancy, Rotary clubs, and other local organizations and volunteers. If you have any questions about the internship program or Tuleyome’s work at the Preserve, please contact Geoff Benn at gbenn@tuleyome.org.
By Bryan Pride October 2, 2025
Thank you to everyone who submitted comments on the proposed rescission of the Roadless Rule and the USDA reorganization. We've cycled through several comment periods over the recent months, including the current open comment period for the rescission of the Public Lands Rule . Your voices joined half a million people who participated in the Roadless Rule comment period with 99% of comments supporting protection of our forest by keeping them roadless. This level of engagement shows the administration that we the people are paying attention. But our work isn’t done. Even though we defeated Senator Lee’s amendment to sell off public lands in the Big Beautiful Bill, the administration is still pursuing that same goal through a more coordinated attack. The mass firing of federal employees, efforts to rescind the Roadless Rule , the Public Lands Rule , and the proposed reorganization of USDA create the conditions necessary for unprecedented extraction from and eventual sale of our public lands. What we're witnessing isn't a series of isolated policy changes, it's a coordinated strategy with the "Big Beautiful Bill" connecting each attack on our public lands. The Strategy The sale of public lands started with DOGE’s mass firing of thousands of experienced Forest Service rangers, BLM land managers, and National Park employees, dedicated public servants who had built expertise from boots-on-the-ground field work to policy development roles. The loss of these public servants also means the elimination of institutional knowledge of what sustainable land management looks like in practice. The administration then moved to make these cuts permanent by closing and selling federal office buildings. The Ukiah BLM office , which manages the Berryessa Snow Mountain National Monument was initially threatened with closure but was eventually removed from the list. Removing the land managers was only one part of the plan. The Big Beautiful Bill passed through Congress with devastating budgetary cuts and protocol mandates for public lands and national forests. The bill, now signed into law, mandates destructive logging quotas : 250 million board feet annually from National Forests and 20 million board feet from BLM lands, with annual quota increases through 2034. The bill also requires agencies to award 20-year logging contracts to private companies, locking in extraction commitments through 2046. Logging levels this high haven't been seen since the 1900s. While the Big Beautiful Bill is now law, agencies cannot implement these logging and extraction mandates unless existing protective regulations, the Roadless Rule and the Public Lands Rule, are rescinded. These rules prevent the Big Beautiful Bill’s quotas from being implemented, which strongly suggests why the administration is moving to eliminate them. The Roadless Rule has coexisted with national forest logging for 25 years. The Rule protects 58.5 million acres of sensitive forest by preventing new road construction in designated roadless areas, while allowing logging to continue in areas with existing roads. However, the mandatory extraction quotas in the Big Beautiful Bill require access to previously untouched, sensitive areas. Meeting these dramatically increased quotas means building roads through currently protected roadless areas. Rescinding the Roadless Rule is a prerequisite for implementing the Big Beautiful Bill’s mandates. The Public Lands Rule recognizes conservation as a legitimate form of multiple use alongside grazing, mining, logging and recreation. The Public Lands Rule hasn’t stopped these uses, it requires that these activities be managed sustainably to protect long-term land health. However, the mandatory extraction minimum in the Big Beautiful Bill prioritizes meeting quotas over sustainable management. Rescinding the Public Lands Rule removes the requirement to balance extraction with conservation, making it possible to prioritize extraction regardless of long-term impacts on public lands. The USDA reorganization completes the strategy by eliminating local expertise, moving California’s forest management out of state. With no local forester position to resist unsustainable quotas or provide expertise about our unique ecosystems, implementation of new extraction protocols becomes inevitable. The sequence reveals the coordination: eliminate the people who understand sustainable management, pass legislation mandating unprecedented extraction, then remove the regulatory barriers that would prevent implementation. Why This Matters Now The Big Beautiful Bill's extraction mandates are already law, but they cannot be implemented while protective rules remain in place. These rules alone make it nearly impossible for the administration to enforce the newly set and unprecedented logging quotas. The protective rules that would prevent devastating extraction practices are under attack. Without these regulatory protections, the already-passed mandates will transform our public lands in ways that may be irreversible. Help speak for our public lands and take action to protect conservation by signing on to Tuleyome’s petition opposing the rescission of the Public Lands Rule, and/or submit comments directly on the Federal Register , you have until November 10th. For more information on how to participate in the public comment process or other advocacy opportunities, contact Bryan Pride Breaking News: Federal Government Shutdown The federal government shut down at 12:01 AM on Wednesday, October 1, 2025. National Parks and public lands will remain open to the public, though each location will vary in the number of staff present. USFS and BLM will have reduced staff at both field offices and regional offices. Some staff will be furloughed, while others may be working without pay. Offices such as the Bureau of Reclamation have the ability to run and operate Lake Berryessa activities for at least two weeks due to their access to discretionary funds, this is not a reality for all agencies. It is fire season. The Department of Interior and Department of Agriculture both released contingency plans for the lapse in federal funding. Both plans state that personnel directly related to wildfire response will largely be exempt from furloughs. The DOI's plan said National Park Service employees involved in fire suppression or fire monitoring activities will not be furloughed. USDA's plan said that employees who respond to and prepare for wildland fires will not be furloughed. Furloughs will still affect employees who are red-carded, or have wildland fire incident qualifications, but whose wildfire duties are secondary to their primary duties . During the government shutdown, some services may not be available or will be delayed. With reduced ranger presence on public lands, take extra precautions: don't hike alone, let someone know your plans, and be sure to pack out what you pack in.